November 22, 2026
4mins

Is it worth upgrading your home when prices fall?

You sell for less, but you buy for less too. Why the gap between the two prices decides an upgrade, a worked example, and the risks a softer market adds.
Is it worth upgrading your home when prices fall?

The short answer: When prices fall, you sell for less but buy for less too, so the number that matters is the gap between the two. In our example, a 5% fall cuts the gap from $400,000 to $380,000. If dearer homes fall further, the saving grows. It's worth it only if you were going to move anyway.

Your sale price isn't the number that matters

When prices soften, the home owners I speak to as a buyers agent tend to fix on the wrong figure: what their own home is now worth. They see it's lower than it was and decide to wait. But if you're selling and buying in the same market, you're a buyer too, and usually of the more expensive home.

What you actually pay to upgrade is the gap between what you sell for and what you buy for, plus the costs of moving.

A worked example

Say you own a townhouse and want to move to a house in the same area. These figures are illustrative, not real sales.

  • Before: you sell the townhouse for $700,000 and buy the house for $1,100,000. The gap is $400,000.
  • Both fall 5%: you sell for $665,000 and buy for $1,045,000. The gap is $380,000.
  • The house falls 8% and the townhouse 3%: you sell for $679,000 and buy for $1,012,000. The gap is $333,000.

Even when both fall by the same percentage, the gap shrinks, because the dearer home falls more in dollars. If houses fall further than townhouses, the gap narrows faster. In the last case, you sell for $21,000 less but upgrade for $67,000 less.

Transfer duty is charged on the price you pay, so a lower purchase price also means less duty. And you may face less competition from other buyers.

What a softer market adds to the risk

The maths can make an upgrade cheaper. It doesn't make it safe.

  • Timing. If you sell first and prices recover before you buy, the saving shrinks. If you buy first and your sale takes months, you carry two properties. Our guide to whether to buy first or sell first covers how to manage it.
  • A slower sale. Homes can take longer to sell in a soft market, and you may need to accept a price near the bottom of your range. Price your own home from recent comparable sales, not from what it was worth at the peak.
  • A bigger loan. A cheaper upgrade is still more debt. Test the repayments at your full pre-approval, and keep a buffer of 6, 9 or 12 months of repayments and costs.
  • Costs on both sides. Agent commission, marketing, legals, moving and duty all come out of the saving.
  • Nobody knows the bottom. Prices can keep falling after you buy. That matters less if you're staying put for ten years, and more if you might move again soon.

Check the gap in your own market

The example is the shape, not your numbers. To work out your own gap:

  1. Price your home from three to five recent comparable sales.
  2. Price two or three homes you'd actually buy, the same way.
  3. Compare the gap with what it would have been a year or two ago, using older sales.
  4. Subtract selling costs, duty and moving costs.

If the gap has narrowed by more than your costs, the upgrade is cheaper than it was. The free Holding Power Check shows what the new repayments look like.

Move for the house, not for the gap

The rule: upgrade because the home fits your life for the next ten years, and let a narrower gap make a planned move cheaper. A smaller gap is a reason to move sooner, not a reason to move.

If you're weighing up a townhouse first, our townhouse body corporate checks cover the costs that don't show in the price. Pricing both sides of an upgrade is part of our work with home buyers. What's the gap between your home and the one you want, today?

Frequently asked questions

Is it a good idea to upgrade your home when prices fall?

It can be, if you were planning to move anyway. You sell for less but buy for less, and the gap between the two prices often shrinks. The risks are timing, a slower sale and a bigger loan.

Should I sell my house when the market is down?

If you're also buying in the same market, a lower sale price is often offset by a lower purchase price. What matters is the gap between the two, less selling, moving and duty costs.

How do I work out the cost of upgrading my home?

Price your home and the homes you'd buy from recent comparable sales, find the gap between them, then add selling costs, transfer duty and moving costs. Test the new repayments before you commit.

Disclaimer: The information in this article is general in nature and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation, or needs. It is not financial, legal, or tax advice. The Nelis Group accepts no liability for actions taken based on this content. You should seek independent advice from a relevant licensed professional before making any decisions and always confirm the latest rules and thresholds with your state revenue office or relevant authority.

James Nelis
Written by
James Nelis

Qualified Property Investment Adviser (QPIA) · Member of Property Investment Professionals of Australia (PIPA)

Founder of The Nelis Group, a boutique buyers agency in Brisbane helping time-poor professionals build durable property portfolios. Structured thinking. No hype.